卡内基国际和平基金会-Russian-Policies-Toward-the-Nordic-Baltic-Region_5页_193kb

Summary of Russian Policies Toward the Nordic-Baltic Region

Core Content

Russia's policies toward the Nordic-Baltic region are part of a broader strategy to engage with Europe and the Atlantic community. These policies have evolved over time, presenting both opportunities and challenges for the region's countries, the EU, and the United States. The region is divided into two distinct groups from Moscow's perspective: the Nordic countries (Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden) and the Baltic states (Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania). Russia's approach to each group is fundamentally different, reflecting historical, cultural, and geopolitical considerations.

Main Policy Goals

Northern Europe

• Security Stability: Ensuring a secure environment for Russia's strategic assets, such as St. Petersburg, the Kola Peninsula, and Kaliningrad.
• Economic Cooperation: Accessing advanced technology and investment from the Nordic countries.
• Baltic Sea Access: Facilitating unimpeded access to Germany via the Baltic Sea, including through pipelines.

Baltic States

• Preventing NATO Infrastructure: Avoiding the deployment of NATO military infrastructure in the region.
• Acquiring Infrastructure Assets: Gaining control of key infrastructure in the Baltic States.
• Citizenship and Language Rights: Encouraging the Baltic States to grant citizenship to Russian-speaking minorities and improve Russian-language education.
• Historical Reconciliation: Acknowledging the Soviet Union's role in liberating Europe from Nazi Germany and addressing historical grievances.

Modernization and Strategic Shifts

The Russian leadership has increasingly focused on modernization as a key priority, which has influenced its foreign policy. This includes:

• Improving Relations with the EU: Seeking closer economic ties, particularly in energy and infrastructure.
• Engaging Nordic Countries: Resolving disputes, such as the Barents Sea border issue with Norway, and collaborating on energy projects like the Shtokman gas field.
• Reconciliation with Baltic States: Initiating diplomatic efforts, such as inviting Latvia's president to Moscow and establishing dialogue with Estonia, to improve relations.

Challenges

Russia's new approach brings two key challenges:

1. Analytical Challenge: Understanding the motivations behind Moscow's overtures and distinguishing between genuine intentions and strategic posturing.
2. Practical Challenge: Coordinating a unified response within NATO and the EU to engage with Russia effectively.

Key Issues for Cooperation

Missile Defense

• Russia opposes NATO's ballistic missile defense system in the Baltic region, fearing it threatens its nuclear deterrent.
• A solution may involve establishing data exchange centers and resuming joint exercises to build trust.
• The goal is to reduce tensions while maintaining European security.

Historical Reconciliation

• Russia needs to address historical grievances, particularly those related to the Soviet occupation of the Baltic states (1939–1949).
• It should acknowledge and condemn the forced annexation and honor the memory of those affected.
• The Baltic states must also re-evaluate their historical narratives and avoid demonizing the Soviet Union.

Energy Cooperation

• Ensuring reliable energy supply to the region, especially after past interruptions in Lithuania.
• Improving safety standards at Russian nuclear facilities, such as in Kaliningrad.
• Encouraging joint Arctic energy exploration with Russian and international companies.
• Addressing the EU's concerns about energy companies "unbundling" and promoting cooperation.

Humanitarian and Economic Issues

• Resolving citizenship and integration issues for Russian-speaking populations in the Baltic States.
• Enhancing people-to-people contacts through transportation projects like the Helsinki–St. Petersburg high-speed train.
• Easing visa restrictions between the Schengen area and Russia to promote mobility and cooperation.

Role of the United States

The United States plays a crucial role in maintaining stability and fostering cooperation in the region:

• Missile Defense: Leading negotiations on cooperative missile defense arrangements with Russia.
• Historical Reconciliation: Supporting the Baltic States in their efforts to normalize relations with Russia.
• Arctic Cooperation: Ensuring peaceful resolution of disputes in the Arctic through multilateral frameworks.
• Leadership and Coordination: Encouraging a unified EU and NATO stance toward Russia, especially on energy and security issues.

Conclusion

Russia's shift toward a more cooperative and less imperialistic approach in the Nordic-Baltic region offers potential for improved relations. However, this requires a nuanced understanding of Moscow's intentions and a coordinated response from the West. The United States, with its influence and resources, is well-positioned to facilitate this process and promote a stable, secure, and cooperative Euro-Atlantic community.