2023-07-13-世界卫生组织-Evaluation_Report_for_DFAT-WHO_water,_sanitation_and_hygiene_WASH_Evaluation_across_the_Asia_Pacific_2018-2022_50页_986kb

报告摘要

Evaluation Summary: DFAT-WHO WASH Program (2018-2022)

The evaluation assessed the effectiveness and value for money (VfM) of the DFAT-supported WHO WASH program across the Asia Pacific region, focusing on Indonesia and the Philippines. The program aimed to strengthen WASH systems for health care facilities and water quality surveillance and management.

Key Findings

Effectiveness

Program Adoption: Strong evidence that program approaches were adopted by governments in Indonesia and the Philippines at the national level, leading to policy changes and commitment.
National Level: Predominant focus was at the national level, with progress evident in policies, guidelines, and monitoring mechanisms. Subnational implementation was limited to smaller scales.
Capacity Building: Training and capacity development were effective, with trained staff leading further training in some areas.

Value for Money

Cost Consciousness: Partner and consultant selection processes were competitive and cost-effective.
Efficiency: Decision-making processes were transparent and prioritized quality delivery, leveraging learning and evidence.
Innovation: Innovative approaches were used to integrate GEDSI and climate resilience, but monitoring and financing gaps remained.

Methodology

Data Sources: Desk reviews, key informant interviews (KIIs), and project documentation.
Scope: Assessed effectiveness and VfM across both technical areas, with a focus on Indonesia and the Philippines.
Limitations: Limited country visits due to COVID-19 and reliance on secondary data.