战略计算：高性能计算以及量子计算在欧洲寻求技术力量中的作用（英）-46页_901kb

Summary of "Strategic Calculation: High-Performance Computing and Quantum Computing in Europe's Quest for Technological Power"

Core Content

This document, authored by Alice Pannier and published by the French Institute of International Relations (Ifri), explores the strategic importance of High-Performance Computing (HPC) and Quantum Computing in the context of global technological competition, particularly between the United States and China, and the role of Europe in this race. It emphasizes how computing power is not just a technical asset but also a geopolitical tool that influences national security, scientific research, economic development, and industrial innovation.

---

Main Points

1. Importance of Computing Power

• Computing power is crucial for:

  • Data analytics and machine learning
  • Cybersecurity
  • Scientific research and medical applications
  • Military uses (e.g., nuclear warhead design, missile defense)
  • Industrial applications (e.g., digital twins, simulations)

• It is a strategic resource that defines control over technology and access to benefits such as AI and other innovations.

2. High-Performance Computing (HPC)

• HPC has been state-driven for decades, used in:

  • National security (nuclear simulations, intelligence)
  • Scientific and medical research
  • Climate modeling and weather forecasting

• Exascale computing is the next level, promising 10^18 operations per second and is the focus of global competition.

• Market dynamics:

  • China and the US dominate the HPC sector.
  • European countries like France, Germany, and the UK have made strides but lag behind.
  • Top HPC vendors include Lenovo, Inspur, HPE, Fujitsu, and Atos.
  • Nvidia has become a key player in HPC due to its GPU technology, which is particularly effective for AI and machine learning.

• Challenges for Europe:

  • Supply chain dependencies on US chipmakers (e.g., AMD, Intel, Nvidia)
  • Export restrictions and geopolitical tensions
  • Lack of private investment in disruptive technologies
  • Internal debates on public procurement and strategic priorities

• EU initiatives:

  • Development of federated computing services and data infrastructure
  • EuroHPC Joint Undertaking to boost European supercomputing capabilities
  • Energy efficiency and technological sovereignty are key goals

3. Quantum Computing

• Quantum computing is in an experimental phase but has highly disruptive potential due to its exponential computing power.

• It has civilian and military applications, including:

  • Cybersecurity (e.g., breaking encryption)
  • Scientific research (e.g., material science, drug discovery)
  • Industrial optimization (e.g., logistics, finance)

• Recent progress:

  • The field has seen rapid advancements, though large-scale quantum computers may still be a decade away.
  • Fugaku (Japan) is currently the world's most powerful supercomputer and is halfway to exascale.

• Strategic competition:

  • The US-China rivalry extends to quantum computing.
  • Europe is catching up through initiatives like the French 2021 Quantum Plan and the EU Quantum Flagship.
  • Pending issues for Europe include:
    • Technological bottlenecks
    • Funding gaps
    • Coordination between member states
    • Lack of a unified strategy

---

Key Information

Global HPC Landscape

• China leads in number of supercomputers, with 188 systems in the Top500 list (37.6% share).
• United States leads in performance, with 122 systems (24.4% share).
• Japan is second in performance with 34 systems (6.8% share).
• Europe has 16 systems (3.2% share), with France, Germany, and the Netherlands being the strongest contributors.

Quantum Computing Landscape

• US and China are the leading players in quantum strategy and investment.
• Europe is developing a quantum ecosystem, with a focus on research, infrastructure, and industrial collaboration.
• The French 2021 Quantum Plan aims to position France as a quantum leader.

Technological and Geopolitical Challenges

• Chips are a critical component of HPC and quantum computing, with Nvidia, AMD, and Intel dominating the market.
• Export restrictions (e.g., US restrictions on Chinese entities) are a major obstacle for European countries reliant on foreign technology.
• Private investment in quantum and HPC technologies is limited in Europe, creating a gap compared to the US and China.
• Energy consumption is a growing concern in the development of high-performance systems.

Future Prospects

• Exascale computing is expected to be deployed by 2022-2023 in Europe.
• Quantum computing is likely to become a major strategic asset in the next decade.
• The democratization of HPC is driven by big data, AI, and cloud computing, allowing more industries to access high-performance capabilities.

---

Conclusion

• HPC and quantum computing are central to Europe’s technological and strategic ambitions.
• Europe must address internal challenges (industrial, technological, political) to compete globally.
• Collective efforts and EU coordination are essential to secure supply chains, foster innovation, and avoid dependency on foreign technologies.
• The race for computing power is not just a technical race, but a geopolitical one, with significant implications for security, economy, and scientific leadership.