20140613-Maybank_KERPL-Avoid_the_herd__Winner_takes_all_74页_2mb

Summary of HK/China Consumer Staples Sector Analysis

Core Content

The HK/China Consumer Staples sector is underperformed by the MSCI Consumer Staples Index, which has lagged behind the HSI/HSCEI by 10% and 7% year-to-date (YTD). The report suggests a prolonged down-cycle for consumer stocks due to weak macroeconomic conditions and a lack of stimulus policies. The key themes identified are complacency among investors and the winner-takes-all dynamics in the sector, favoring large-cap companies over smaller ones.

Main Points

1. Complacency in the Sector

• Investors are holding onto consensus longs despite deteriorating fundamentals.
• Biostime is reiterated as a contrarian SELL due to the end of the "golden age" of infant milk formula. The market is now flooded with "100% imported with original packaging" products, which dilute Biostime's competitive edge.
• Mengniu is downgraded to a non-consensus SELL due to rising competition and expected margin pressures from aggressive promotions and a shift in consumer preference away from UHT milk.
• Tingyi, Want Want, and Hengan are highlighted for their favorable risk-reward profiles.

2. Winner Takes All

• The report forecasts that well-established companies will extend their comparative advantages over smaller competitors.
• Large companies are expected to benefit from improved gross margins due to:
  • Moderate increases in raw material costs
  • Solid mix improvements
  • More disciplined promotional strategies
• M&A opportunities are anticipated, and companies with strong financial positions are better positioned to consolidate and expand through horizontal integration.
• The sector is expected to enter a low-growth era, where organic growth will be limited and strategic acquisitions will be key to success.

3. Valuation Considerations

• The sector is trading at a 24x 12-month rolling forward PER, a 20% premium to the five-year average of 20x.
• Selectivity is emphasized, as the sector is not cheap.
• The report suggests cherry-picking stocks with strong fundamentals and growth potential.

Key Companies and Ratings

Key Investment Calls

Top Call #1: Biostime - The Golden Era of Infant Milk Formula Ends

• Biostime is reiterated as a contrarian SELL.
• The rise of "100% imported with original packaging" products is diluting its competitive advantage.
• Aggressive promotions and price competition are expected to continue.
• The market is anticipated to see a shift in consumer preference towards more affordable and healthy alternatives.
• The company's recent marketing campaign on JD.com is a key factor in its underperformance.

Top Call #2: China Mengniu - 'Milk Deluxe' is No Longer a Deluxe

• China Mengniu is downgraded to a non-consensus SELL.
• Increased competition and pressure on ASPs and A&P are key concerns.
• Consumer preference is shifting away from UHT milk to healthier alternatives.
• The company faces challenges from both imported and domestic brands, with rising promotional activity.

Top Call #3: Winner Takes All

• The report emphasizes the importance of scale and integration in a low-growth environment.
• Large companies like Tingyi and Hengan are expected to outperform due to better cost control, higher margins, and strategic product launches.
• Tingyi is highlighted for its strong EPS CAGR prospects and improved operating efficiency.
• Hengan is noted for its strong performance in the sanitary napkins and tissue segments, with potential to gain market share from competitors like Johnson & Johnson.

Industry Overview and Outlook

Instant Noodles

• The sector has seen stagnation in volume, with Tingyi leading in both value and volume.
• The market is dominated by braised beef noodles, with Laotan now in second place.
• Product upgrades and price increases are expected to drive growth.

Beverages (Ex-Dairy & Beer)

• The sector growth has slowed, but bottled water remains a bright spot.
• Functional and sports drinks, as well as traditional Asian beverages, are also showing growth.
• Tingyi leads in the ready-to-drink tea category, with over 50% market share by value and 60% by volume.
• Uni-President is the second-largest player with about 30% market share.

Conclusion

The report recommends avoiding the herd and focusing on selective investment in the Consumer Staples sector. It highlights the importance of market leadership, cost control, and strategic integration in a low-growth environment. The focus is on large-cap companies that can sustain growth through innovation and efficiency, while smaller players face increasing pressure due to competition and margin constraints.