世界发展银行-Hydrological-Risk_33页_1mb

Summary of Technical Note 1: Hydrological Risk

Core Content

This Technical Note provides guidance on managing hydrological risk in dam safety projects. It outlines the importance of hydrological data, modeling techniques, and the impact of climate change on flood characteristics. The Note is part of the Good Practice Note on Dam Safety, aimed at supporting project preparation and implementation by offering a structured approach to hydrological risk assessment.

Main Objectives

• To provide guidance on the hydrological aspects of dam projects.
• To raise awareness about hydrological risk in the context of dam safety.
• To assist in selecting appropriate modeling techniques and data management practices.
• To inform the preparation of terms of reference and the evaluation of consultant proposals.

Key Topics Covered

1. Hydrological Risk Overview

Hydrological risk is a critical factor in all phases of a dam project:

• Design Phase: Ensures the dam is sized appropriately to handle extreme flows.
• Construction Phase: Focuses on the risk of uncontrolled inflows that could lead to cofferdam breaches and downstream flooding.
• Operations Phase: Concerns the ability of flow control systems to manage inflows and prevent dam overtopping and structural failure.

Hydrological risk is linked to:

• Establishing characteristics of extreme events.
• Designing and sizing discharge facilities.
• Developing operating strategies and plans.

2. Data Management

• Essential Data Types:

  • Hydrometric Data: River stage, sediment yield, ice conditions.
  • Climatological Data: Precipitation, snow survey, solar radiation, evaporation, temperature, humidity, wind.

• Data Requirements:

  • Sufficient data length and frequency are crucial for accurate modeling.
  • In cases of limited data, regional data can be used to supplement local records.
  • ERA5 Database is recommended for projects with scarce data, offering rainfall and potential evapotranspiration data.

• Data Quality:

  • Importance of data validation and quality control.
  • Guidance from WMO 2008 on data collection and processing.

• Data Management Tools:

  • For good data availability, a computerized database should be developed.
  • For poor data availability, simpler tools can be used effectively.

3. Watershed and River System Models

• These models are essential for:

  • Assessing how climate and weather affect streamflow.
  • Simulating flood behavior and evaluating water resource management options.

• Model Types:

  • Empirical Models: Use statistical relationships and are suitable for simpler or small-scale projects.
  • Conceptual Models: Simplify physical processes while capturing essential dynamics.
  • Physically Based Models: Represent real-world hydrological processes with high accuracy.

• Common Models:

  • GR4J, HBV, IHACRES, HEC-HMS, Mike 11, TOPKAPI-X, MIKE-SHE.
  • These models vary in complexity and can be used for different project stages.

• Model Selection Criteria:

  • Engineer experience and knowledge.
  • Ability to represent all relevant hydrological processes.
  • Data availability and compatibility.
  • Calibration and validation requirements.

4. Probabilistic Characterization of Floods

• Flood Frequency Analysis is a common method for estimating flood risk.

  • Uses statistical distributions and can be conducted at a single site or regionally.
  • Single-site analysis is suitable for sites with long records.
  • Regional analysis is recommended for areas with short records or rare floods.

• Software Tools:

  • HYFRAN-Plus, HEC-SSP, peakfqSA, CumFreq.
  • These tools assist in statistical analysis and frequency estimation.

• Climate Change Considerations:

  • Recent approaches focus on nonstationarity in hydroclimatic data.
  • Adjustments to traditional methods are necessary to account for changing climate patterns.

5. Probable Maximum Precipitation (PMP) and Probable Maximum Flood (PMF)

• PMP is the theoretical maximum precipitation for a given duration under modern meteorological conditions.
• PMF is the response of the watershed to PMP, representing the maximum possible flood.
• The Hershfield method is a practical approach for calculating PMP.

6. Glacial Lake Outburst Flood (GLOF)

• GLOFs are a significant source of extreme flooding in high-mountain catchments with glaciers and glacial lakes.
• As climate change causes glacier retreat, the number and size of potentially hazardous GLOF sources may increase.
• Initial assessments and inventory of glacial lakes are recommended for such areas.
• Multiphase assessments (e.g., satellite studies, high-resolution surveys) may be necessary for high-risk dams.

7. Other Flood Characterization Methods

• Deterministic Methods are used when data is scarce.
  • These methods estimate flood characteristics based on known inputs and relationships.
  • Empirical formulas and curves are commonly used to estimate peak discharge.

Key Information

• Hydrological data is essential for all stages of dam project planning and operation.
• Watershed models and river system models are key tools for assessing flood risk and managing dam safety.
• Probabilistic methods and regional analysis help in estimating flood characteristics, especially in data-limited environments.
• Climate change introduces nonstationarity into hydrological data, requiring updated modeling approaches.
• GLOF is a critical risk in high-mountain regions and should be assessed as part of hydrological risk management.
• The World Bank encourages the use of WMO 2008 guidance and provides a list of recommended models and software for different purposes.

References and Additional Sources

• WMO 2008 provides a comprehensive guide on hydrological practices.
• Hosking (1997), ICOLD (2014, 2016b), and WMO (2009a) offer detailed guidance on flood frequency analysis.
• Edsel et al. (2011), Singh (1995), and Sitterson et al. (2017) provide extensive lists of hydrological models.
• Hartford et al. (2016) outlines current watershed modeling approaches.
• Mondal and Denzil (2018) and Volpi (2018) discuss adjustments for nonstationarity in flood frequency analysis.

Conclusion

This Technical Note serves as a practical guide for managing hydrological risk in dam projects. It emphasizes the importance of data quality, appropriate modeling techniques, and the integration of climate change considerations. The document aims to assist project teams in making informed decisions during the planning, design, and operation phases of dam projects.